You are never fully liberated from Auschwitz, 11 July 2016 Author: Red-125 from Upstate New York The French movie "À la vie" was shown in the U.S. with the translated title "To Life (2014)." It was written and directed by Jean-Jacques Zilbermann. The film is a Post-Holocaust saga, although it opens with scenes in Auschwitz that are truly horrific. Hélène (Julie Depardieu) and Lily (Johanna ter Steege) were friends in Auschwitz, and they managed to survive the death march from Auschwitz to Louslau together. A third friend, Rose (Suzanne Clément) was unable to walk, so they were forced to leave her behind. As it turned out, Rose survived until the liberation of Auschwitz. The three did not see each other again until 1962, when they come together for a reunion at a beachside resort in Northern France. We learn early in the movie that Lily divorced her husband after the war, and is living as a "free soul," with no permanent partner. Hélène and Rose both married concentration camp survivors. The plot of the film--based on the lives of three actual friends--revolves around their interactions during the reunion. No matter how much ice cream they eat, and how they display their new bathing suits, thoughts keep circling back to Auschwitz. They quarrel about tiny details which they remember differently. They revive horrible memories. It's clear that the reunion will change their lives, but whether the change will be for the better or for the worse is an open question. For reasons I don't understand, "To Life" caries a terrible IMDb rating of 6.1. Fortunately, we saw it as part of the excellent Rochester Jewish Film Festival. If we hadn't had "All-Event" tickets, we probably would have stayed home. This is a movie to be seen, not missed. Ignore the rating and seek it out. It's available on DVD, and it will work well on the small screen. See it!
剧情三星，结尾值得加一星，我更偏向本体活下来的说法（ps原来是星云啊，我就说女主很熟悉！）
整个剧情都相当之荒诞，跳跃！喝那瓶水真的很傻缺！
是小粉吉兰的健身操
这部电影科幻部分很少，仅仅体现在克隆技术上，其他部分与当下世界无异，甚至感觉里面制定法律法规粗暴简单！到最后我也不关心哪个活下来，因为不被需要那个已经”死去“！
前面很不错，结局有点突然和欠味道。凯伦·吉兰好像没以前好看了。
本是一个荒诞的科幻制度为基础，聚焦在女主自绝症，亲友的冷淡，寄希望于克隆人的传承，到最后被克隆人“剥夺”了人生，导演没有刻意藏匿线索，稍动点脑就能知道结局，我杀死了那个他们蓄谋的“我”，并陪他们孤独的装成我，好无奈悲剧的结局。
喜欢第一和第三个故事，前者是对未知的恐惧慢慢探索，最后来一个柯南伯格式的身体恐怖，而后者也一样是以身体恐怖继续延展，恐怖的地方不在于形象，而是那个异化过程。
还是挺有意思的电影。尤其是喜欢后半段多一点。不过这种类型的电影确实也有点麻烦就是。一人分饰两角。很容易混淆。
短篇版《黑镜》。主角苦练格斗一年，最后被克隆人阴了。原来克隆人练的是智力。
其实女主是否存活对于这个电影的叙事已经不再重要，尽管如此，我觉得大家还是要耐心一点把电影全程看完再做评价。否则各种似是而非的误导真的让人遗憾。
一般，但是可以讲的更好。克隆人比本体更能被家庭和伴侣接纳，意味着我们不在乎的你是否是一个人，仅仅在乎的是你是否满足了家庭/伴侣的情感需要。其中设定有一点不合理，说如果克隆人存在时间够长，有了自己的意识后，就有相应的法律支持它的权益，它可以和本体决斗，决定谁能留存。但是从人的角度来看，刚出生的孩子不管有没有意识，他/她都是一个人，都应该活下来。
人生就是一杯咖啡，闻着是香的，尝起是苦的。
故事框架挺好的。拍得太没趣味，而且拖沓无味，太不美国了。
克隆体其实和本体无论外形还是性格都是类似的，她出生的那天就知道自己必须比本体做得更好才可能替代本体。所以对男友温柔，主动讨好母亲，更注重仪表礼仪。从两人徒步本体训练一年都跟不上克隆体来看，克隆体的锻炼绝不比本体少。她的大哭，是因为所有的努力都是违心的，她和本体一样不想一辈子只是活成别人心目中的好人标准。转盘路上，不会开车的她连逆行都不明白，也许她的人生，根本就是一种知难而上的逆行，无法回头。
芬兰的片子，芬兰果然是个压抑的国家，看得人太压抑了……从电影的主题，到色调，到这个从开头让人不喜欢到结尾的主演，怎一个压抑了得，看的人心情极差，看得我都跟男朋友分手了
看了这么多评论，所以说，结局到底是什么呢？谁杀了我，我又杀了谁？
开放结局，最后活下来的可以是本体也可以是克隆体，每个结果都能脑补出前面被隐去的剧情。
这部恐怖和猎奇感都齐了，弗兰森斯坦那部分是加分项，竟然还加入了嘲讽白人至上主义的元素。
我本来以为活下来的是克隆，看评论又觉得是本体
抛开不是重点的逻辑，真是看得憋气又窝火。女主的人生太可悲了，一个人如果无私无我，那世界上有没有这个人又有什么关系呢。这就是女主的困境，死了就死了吧，解脱了，也许二重身呢走出这个困境呢。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
