Fernando Di Leo's "Milano Calibro 9" is an out-and-out masterpiece of Italian Crime cinema and, in my opinion, one of the most astonishing crime stories ever told. The first film in Di Leo's excellent 'Milieu' trilogy, "Milano Calibro 9" was followed by "La Mala Ordina" (aka. "Manhunt", also 1972) and the brilliant "Il Boss" (1973). The three films are not connected story-wise, but all three are excellent, and highly realistic portrayals of organized crime. As far as I am concerned "Manhunt" is (allthough excellent) slightly inferior to this one and "Il Boss" which both stand out as absolute all-time highlights of crime cinema. "Milano Calibro 9" is the best of them all, a film that is astonishing in all aspects, be it the ingenious plot that, apart from a compelling story and clever twists, includes social criticism, the performances, the gritty atmosphere and suspense or the brilliant score. I can hardly find the right words to express my admiration for this masterpiece which easily ranks among the greatest Gangster flicks ever brought to screen.
Gastone Moschin stars as Ugo Piazza, a tough and elliptical ex-convict who has just been released from prison. Immediately after his release, Ugo is approached by members of the Milan mob lead by the irascible gangster Rocco (Mario Adorf), as they suspect him to be responsible for the disappearance of a large sum of money belonging to their boss, an American (Lionel Stander) who controls the organized crime in Milan...
"Milano Calibro 9" is a film that delivers an astonishingly realistic mood of the underworld like hardly another. The intriguing storyline goes in hand with interesting characters, raw atmosphere, suspense and breathtaking action, social criticism and brutal violence. The film is simply stunning from the beginning to the end, which is even intensified by the brilliant score, a collaboration of the famous composer Luis Enríquez Bacalov and the Italian Progressive Rock band Osanna. Ugo Piazza must be one of the most charismatic gangster characters ever in cinema, and Gastone Moschin was the prefect choice for the role. Moschin delivers a brilliant performance, and the rest of the cast is also great. Mario Adorf is irascible like a rabid dog as the ferocious gangster Rocco, a role that fits him like a glove. The great Lionel Stander fits perfectly in his role of the American Mafia Don.
The two cop characters in the film are played by two of the greatest regulars of Italian genre-cinema, Luigi Pistilli and Frank Wolff (who committed suicide before the film was released). The ravishing Barbara Bouchet is astonishing and incredibly sexy in the role of Ugo Piazza's stripper girlfriend. Bouchet is both a stunning beauty and an excellent actress and this is doubtlessly one of her most memorable roles. This is also a political film and director Di Leo embedded a lot of social criticism about topics like corruption. This film simply has everything one can possibly desire in cinema. Films like "Milano Calibro 9" are the reason why I love cinema. This is an absolute masterpiece in all regards and, without exaggeration, one of the greatest Crime flicks ever made! The ingenious opening scene alone is more memorable than most films get in two hours.
真好，如果你静下心来进入角色用心去看这部片子，就如同父亲用手去感受女儿的歌声一样。
朴实感人。就是学校的部分因为残疾而被歧视bully有点刻意
合格的翻拍作品，但还是觉得原版更加朴实动人~
非著名导演和非热度演员制造了这么一部踏实感人自然又流畅的拿奖季大热好片。会讲故事的叙事方式，会拿捏的真实演技，会催人流泪的简单情节，会给人勇气的主旨表达，在这个标榜独特和个性的电影市场显得格外难得。最后聋哑父亲发出的那句“go”一下就让我破防了。上帝那么不公平的让人生来有残缺，但却从来没有夺走爱的力量和勇气。
暖心、疗愈。// Mr. V这样执着于本念的老师是多么可贵、可爱。 // Family, makes one hate them to an extent that one eventually realizes this feeling is actually love. // “I’ve looked at clouds from both sides now, from up and down, and still somehow, it’s cloud illusions I recall, I really don’t know clouds at all.”
身体的缺陷，意味了社会欲望的删减，让夫妻更加恩爱，让这家人更加亲密。把事业与梦想在内的社会关系讲述得略显理想化，对人物情感的表达却又极其真实。女性镜头下的爱与家庭，温暖而坚实。
在这么悲苦的底色下讲了个阳光乐观的故事，有点厉害。相比原版，这一部节奏畅快得多，女主也是人中龙凤级的美丽，原生家庭明明个个混球，导演却刻意回避了那些没心没肺的索取，是为了最后能凑个happy ending吗？一家人的转变不能说不合理，但实在感动不起来。属于一定得不到奥斯卡但又一定属于奥斯卡系的配菜，就酱。
得力于原著本子的扎实，改编后依旧是佳作，但没想到能问鼎最佳影片，或许在疫情，战争大背景下，在所有提名的影片中，她最能带给我们希望。
整体的叙事安排都挺好的，女主的颜我也是吃的，但就是唱歌段落的表演，摆脱不开glee和歌舞青春的影子。
温情片，生活那么苦，很需要这种甜而不腻、笑过之后也有悲伤的电影！ 在女主演唱时，从正常人到聋人视觉的切换，创意很棒，不自觉地掉下眼泪。 PS女主男友好帅，正好比我大十几天出生，可以和我在一起，很合适。
我一直觉得 听觉可能是我最容易放弃的五感之一 但是对于听障来说 唉……
7.5分。女主角人美歌甜，有几幕的设计相当动人，没了。 不知道谁是把CODA翻译成《健听女孩》的始作俑者，非常不恰当。 CODA是“聋人子女”（Children of Deaf Adults）的缩写，据统计聋人生养的孩子90%以上都是听力正常的，所以CODA这个缩写代表的是一个特殊群体，他们是掌握口语和手语的双语者，扮演着连接聋人家长与健听人世界的角色，正如电影里所表现的那样。 而所谓“健听人”通常指的是与聋人毫无关系的广大听力正常人群，用这个词来指身为CODA的女主角是不合适的。《健听女孩》这个标题也压根不切题。另外，作为医学术语，“健听”是香港说法，其实就是英语的normal hearing，大陆直接译作“听力正常”不好吗，别扭的表达会妨碍概念的传播。
标准的好莱坞校园俗套，没有欧式的厚重感，还鸡汤熬得过火。本片的价值所在就是听了几首一般歌，伯克利这么好上，知道了原版《贝利叶一家》，分数炒的比原版还高。为了制造冲突而冲突，聋哑母亲祈祷孩子是聋哑人竟然是母爱，真心理解不了这观点。一家人没她又不行的样子，好像一家人都是她生出来的。开头一身的鱼腥味还以为是《燃野少年的天空》。3
有声和无声完全是两个世界，幸好还有手语架起了爱的桥梁。
大概是奥斯卡里和《沙丘》并列我最喜欢的影片了…爸爸值得一个最佳男配的，如果最佳影片是这个真的就好了（感觉好难…
看过一模一样的一部电影，但结尾还是一直在哭。
一种工整流畅同时也套路的好看。全片最触动我的两个点，一个就是我能感受到这一家人之间的爱，既害怕失去又尝试放手的那种爱；还有一个就是最后的拥抱，告别很难，回望很久，我懂。法版觉得鸡汤的部分，这一版居然意外吃下了，生活好苦，总要有些东西来麻痹自己日子还是值得过的，至少在某些方面是这样。3.5
毫无疑问这是一部在很多地方较为俗套的影片，但除了呈现温馨，励志与欢乐之外，影片也用较为轻松的方式表达了对聋哑群体的关注，后半段“与哥哥观念上的争论”，“无声的歌曲与有声的演唱”，“手语的歌词”三段连杀确乎工整且漂亮。
有些细节处理的不错 ，但是还是法版好看。好莱坞的原创力也越累越乏善可陈了。
看过法版再看这部，剧情虽然已经不新鲜了，但还是会感动，尤其所有演唱的段落，非常真挚又扎心，这个家庭里唯一健全的孩子被他们以爱的名义捆绑，父母时而温馨时而自私的表现也是很真实了，当然电影里是女孩以做自己收尾，实际生活中不知道有多少女孩折戟了梦想，成了那个“家”的依靠。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
